Cowboy boots have a reputation for being expensive, but the Rhodes ATX Western Boot (often called the Rhodes Roper Boot) is here to challenge that idea. Marketed as an affordable roper that can handle just about anything, the ATX offers classic Western styling at a price point that won’t make your wallet ache.
I recently picked up a pair from Huckberry.com, and in this review I’ll break down the details from design, materials, comfort, sizing, to the pros and cons so you can decide if this roper is the right fit for you.
Subscribe to my YouTube Channel for more in depth content
What Makes a Roper Boot?
Before diving into the specifics, let’s define what makes a roper different from other cowboy boots.
- Shaft Height: Around 10 inches tall (shorter than a traditional cowboy boot).
- Heel: A low, square heel, usually around 1 inch.
- Toe Shape: Typically round, offering a bit more room than pointed or narrow toes.
The Rhodes ATX checks all of these boxes: a 10-inch shaft, 1-inch roper heel, and a round toe designed for all-day wear. This combination makes ropers a versatile option for work, casual wear, and anything in between.
First Impressions
The Rhodes ATX comes across as clean and straightforward. My pair is in a Tobacco Honey Suede Brown Cork colorway which is easy to style with jeans and casual outfits. At first glance, you’ll notice that these boots lean simple in design, but sometimes less is more.
The shaft is made of unlined suede, giving it a soft and flexible feel. That means they slip under jeans easily and don’t create bulk. However, these thin unlined shafts will also sag more quickly, so if you prefer a crisp, upright look, you might want to use boot shapers when storing them. Personally, I like the sagged-in look. It feels worn-in and authentic.
Shop the Rhodes ATX Western Boot at Huckberry.com
Materials and Build
Here’s the breakdown of what you’re actually getting:
- Foot & Counter: Full-grain leather (a bovine leather that feels durable).
- Shaft: Thin suede/rough-out leather, unlined for flexibility.
- Welt: 360° leather welt sewn to a leather midsole (resolable).
- Outsole: Rubber Vibram sole glued on to the leather midsole
- Heel: 1-inch roper heel made from the same Vibram material.
- Lining: Unlined top and leather-lined foot with a soft cowhide feel.
- Insole: Removable foam insole topped with leather.
- Footbed: Compressed cardboard (a cost-saving choice, and not ideal for heavy-duty work).
Overall, the Rhodes ATX is a resolable boot with decent materials for the price point. The Vibram outsole is a highlight, offering durability and grip.
Comfort and Fit
Slipping into the Rhodes ATX, the first thing I noticed was that they run a bit narrow. Though they’re sold as a D-width, they feel closer to a C-width. The toe box is wide enough, so my toes didn’t feel pinched, but across the instep the fit is tighter than average.
If you’re considering these boots, I recommend sizing up a half size. Unfortunately, Rhodes only offers this boot in one width, which limits the audience. Competitors like Red Wing offer multiple widths, and that makes a huge difference for comfort.
The removable insole is thick, soft, and lined with leather, which adds cushion but also takes up space inside the boot. If you need a little more room, swapping it for a thinner insole could help.
Break-in will take some time since you’re dealing with a leather midsole and a rubber outsole, but the payoff is a boot that molds to your foot.
Shop the Rhodes ATX Western Boot at Huckberry.com
Style and Versatility
The Rhodes ATX is not a flashy cowboy boot. It’s built to be understated and versatile. The suede shaft slips easily under denim, and since it’s soft, it won’t show through your jeans. That makes it a great everyday boot for casual wear.
If you like the rugged, broken-in look, these boots will deliver quickly. The suede shaft will sag naturally, creating that relaxed, lived-in character. Pair them with straight or athletic-cut jeans, and you’ll have a clean Western style that works anywhere.
Price and Value
At the time of my purchase, these boots were available at Huckberry for around $160–$175. At that price, the Rhodes ATX offers great value. You’re getting a resolable leather-welted boot with a Vibram outsole—something you don’t usually see at this price point.
However, the retail price can climb to $260–$270, and at that level, the value proposition changes. For that price, you’re competing with brands like Red Wing, which offer multiple widths and slightly higher-grade construction. If Rhodes expanded their sizing options, they’d have a stronger case at the higher tier.
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Affordable at the $160–$175 range
- Classic roper style with a low heel and round toe
- Vibram outsole adds durability and grip
- Resoleable construction with 360° leather welt
- Flexible suede shaft fits easily under jeans
- Removable cushioned insole for comfort
Cons:
- Runs narrow (size up a half size recommended)
- Only offered in D-width, which limits accessibility
- Suede shaft will sag quickly (a pro or con depending on taste)
- Compressed cardboard footbed isn’t ideal for heavy wear or wet conditions
- At higher retail prices ($260+), better options exist
How They Compare
At the entry-level price point, the Rhodes ATX punches above its weight. Compared to other boots in the $160 range, you’re getting resoleability and a Vibram sole, which is rare.
But at the higher end of its retail pricing, it struggles against competitors like Red Wing Pecos. Red Wing offers six width options and more robust construction, making them a better buy if you’re willing to spend closer to $300.
Who Are These Boots For?
The Rhodes ATX Western Boot is best suited for:
- Casual wearers who want a stylish roper for everyday outfits.
- Budget-conscious buyers looking for resolable boots under $200.
- Newcomers to cowboy boots who want an affordable entry point.
- Fans of Huckberry who like curated, versatile menswear options.
They’re not the best choice if you need a heavy-duty work boot or if you have wide feet, since sizing options are limited.
Final Thoughts
The Rhodes ATX Western Boot is a solid entry-level roper that offers great style and versatility at an affordable price. At the $160–$175 range, they’re an excellent value, especially for those who want an everyday boot that pairs easily with jeans.
They do have limitations: narrow fit, only one width, and a less durable footbed. But for casual wear, these boots will serve you well and they look good doing it.
If Rhodes can expand their sizing options, they’ll compete more strongly in the $250+ space. Until then, the ATX remains a strong contender in the affordable roper category.
Verdict: If you’re looking for a stylish, budget-friendly roper boot with resolable construction, the Rhodes ATX is worth a try just make sure to size up.